Amphithéâtre Marguerite de Navarre, Site Marcelin Berthelot
Open to all
-

Abstract

The session begins with a recapitulation of the proposals and ambitions of last year's lecture, based on the notion of a generative grammar of the possibilities of politics in the Middle Ages. We hypothesized that its rules of transformation were only conceivable from a single focus of production that lay outside the field of the political, since the paradox of medieval Christianity is that it confers authority on those who admit the unworthiness of power. Two equally counter-intuitive propositions can be drawn from this : the first is that medieval societies lived under the sign ofexceptio, and that the relative robustness of domination is explained less by the constricting compactness of man's framework than by his ability to extricate himself from it. The second is that the system of powers holds together because it makes possible, or thinkable, the possibility of another political becoming, which it keeps at a distance but within sight, in distant, heteroptic forms of community, or fictions. Through the question of political fictions, then, we return to the problem of the articulation between narration and experience. We propose to introduce the main issues at stake, based on an exercise in historical micro-reading : an extract from Guillaume de Saint-Pathus's Vie de Saint Louis , in which we hear the outburst of a woman named Sarrete, dissatisfied with royal policy.

Contents

  • Resuming negotiations: looking for the highlight
  • "Everything interesting happens in the shadows...": a childhood memory a childhood memory
  • "I'll talk as long as you're amazed", says Menocchio
  • Mathieu Riboulet, Les Portes de Thèbes, 2020
  • Carlo Ginzburg's cunning game of quotations in Le Fromage et les vers : Brecht, Benjamin, Céline and Bloch
  • Voyage au bout de la nuit : from "Everything interesting happens in the shadows, decidedly. We know nothing of the true history of men" to " In some brains, magnificent efforts of imagination are made "
  • Reminder of the ambitions and proposals of the 2019 lecture: mapping the emergence of politics, proposing a generative grammar of medieval powers
  • Two counter-intuitive hypotheses on the possibilities of politics in the Middle Ages
  • Narrative and experience: first definitions
  • "For to the question: 'How did things happen in reality?' we can answer with certainty: 'In reality things did not happen in a narrative'" (Pascal Quignard, Life is not a Biography, 2019)
  • The power of narrative and the economy of attention: capture and emancipation
  • Second micro-reading exercise: Sarrete's outburst in Guillaume de Saint-Pathus's Vie de Saint Louis
  • Voices other than the king's: "Guillaume de Saint-Pathus's Saint Louis is the collective creation of the trial's witnesses" (Jacques Le Goff)
  • Mout miex fust que un autre fust roi que tu es : female intrusion and the king's "vigorous patience
  • Protest, protest, deliberation: on the steps of Parliament
  • "Le roman du châtelain de Coucy et de la dame de Fayel": mythical memory and political fiction
  • An "oppositional public space" (Oskar Negt)
  • For the rest, we can't reconstruct Sarrete's forgotten life on the strength of such a little noise
  • This "immense possibility of discourse" (Michel Foucault)
  • "To tell stories is to contribute to scripting the future behavior of those we address" (Yves Citton, Mythocratie, 2010)
  • Diderot's irony: "everything good and bad that happens to us down here was written up there"(Jacques le fataliste et son maître)